From edb216849e4f47d6cae95981edf0c3fe2653fd7a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001

From: Rob Crittenden <rcritten@redhat.com>

Date: Fri, 28 Jan 2022 16:46:35 -0500

Subject: [PATCH] Don't always override the port in import_included_profiles

I can only guess to the original purpose of this override. I

believe it was because this is called in the installer prior

to Apache being set up. The expectation was that this would

only be called locally. It predates the RestClient class.

RestClient will attempt to find an available service. In this

case, during a CA installation, the local server is not

considered available because it lacks an entry in

cn=masters. So it will never be returned as an option.

So by overriding the port to 8443 the remote connection will

likely fail because we don't require that the port be open.

So instead, instantiate a RestClient and see what happens.

There are several use-cases:

1. Installing an initial server. The RestClient connection

   should fail, so we will fall back to the override port and

   use the local server. If Apache happens to be running with

   a globally-issued certificate then the RestClient will

   succeed. In this case if the connected host and the local

   hostname are the same, override in that case as well.

2. Installing as a replica. In this case the local server should

   be ignored in all cases and a remote CA will be picked with

   no override done.

3. Switching from CA-less to CA-ful. The web server will be

   trusted but the RestClient login will fail with a 404. Fall

   back to the override port in this case.

The motivation for this is trying to install an EL 8.x replica

against an EL 7.9 server. 8.5+ includes the ACME service and

a new profile is needed which doesn't exist in 7. This was

failing because the RestClient determined that the local server

wasn't running a CA so tried the remote one (7.9) on the override

port 8443. Since this port isn't open: failure.

Chances are that adding the profile is still going to fail

because again, 7.9 lacks ACME capabilities, but it will fail in

a way that allows the installation to continue.

I suspect that all of the overrides can similarly handled, or

handled directly within the RestClient class, but for the sake

of "do no harm" I'm only changing this instance for now.

https://pagure.io/freeipa/issue/9100

Signed-off-by: Rob Crittenden <rcritten@redhat.com>

Reviewed-By: Florence Blanc-Renaud <frenaud@redhat.com>

---

 ipaserver/install/cainstance.py | 30 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-

 1 file changed, 29 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)

diff --git a/ipaserver/install/cainstance.py b/ipaserver/install/cainstance.py

index 8c8bf1b3a..ad206aad4 100644

--- a/ipaserver/install/cainstance.py

+++ b/ipaserver/install/cainstance.py

@@ -1953,7 +1953,35 @@ def import_included_profiles():

         cn=['certprofiles'],

     )

-    api.Backend.ra_certprofile.override_port = 8443

+    # At this point Apache may or may not be running with a valid

+    # certificate. The local server is not yet recognized as a full

+    # CA yet so it isn't discoverable. So try to do some detection

+    # on what port to use, 443 (remote) or 8443 (local) for importing

+    # the profiles.

+    #

+    # api.Backend.ra_certprofile invokes the RestClient class

+    # which will discover and login to the CA REST API. We can

+    # use this information to detect where to import the profiles.

+    #

+    # If the login is successful (e.g. doesn't raise an exception)

+    # and it returns our hostname (it prefers the local host) then

+    # we override and talk locally.

+    #

+    # Otherwise a NetworkError means we can't connect on 443 (perhaps

+    # a firewall) or we get an HTTP error (valid TLS certificate on

+    # Apache but no CA, login fails with 404) so we override to the

+    # local server.

+    #

+    # When override port was always set to 8443 the RestClient could

+    # pick a remote server and since 8443 isn't in our firewall profile

+    # setting up a new server would fail.

+    try:

+        with api.Backend.ra_certprofile as profile_api:

+            if profile_api.ca_host == api.env.host:

+                api.Backend.ra_certprofile.override_port = 8443

+    except (errors.NetworkError, errors.RemoteRetrieveError) as e:

+        logger.debug('Overriding CA port: %s', e)

+        api.Backend.ra_certprofile.override_port = 8443

     for (profile_id, desc, store_issued) in dogtag.INCLUDED_PROFILES:

         dn = DN(('cn', profile_id),

-- 

2.34.1